A Fall Down an Open Stairway: How We Won at Trial After the First Verdict Went Wrong
A real Wisconsin safe-place case — and what it shows about proving a fall case, a spouse’s own claim, and making an insurance company pay for refusing a fair settlement.
Our client and her husband arrived at a restaurant and found their table was not ready. As she stepped back from the host’s podium to wait, she fell down an open stairway and was seriously hurt. The restaurant blamed her, offered nothing before trial, and fought the case through two trials and an appeal. In the end, a jury held the restaurant responsible, and our clients recovered the full verdict — plus interest and double costs. Here is what the case shows about questions injured people ask us most.
“My injury doesn’t sound that serious — can my case still be worth a lot?”
Yes. The value of an injury case is not about how dramatic the treatment sounds; it is about the real, provable harm the injury causes to your life. An injury that does not require surgery can still be serious, painful, and disabling — and worth substantial compensation — when its true effect is proven. Do not let an insurance company talk you out of your claim by saying your injury “wasn’t that bad.”
Our client suffered a fractured wrist that did not require surgery; it was treated with an external fixator device. The defense treated that as a reason the case was worth little. The jury did not agree. When the real, lasting effect of the injury was presented, the damages were substantial — far more than the insurance company had been willing to consider.
“Does my spouse have a claim too?”
Often, yes. When someone is seriously injured, their husband or wife may have a separate claim for loss of society and companionship — the real loss of the shared life, support, and partnership the injury takes away. It is a claim that belongs to the spouse, and it is often overlooked.
Our client’s husband recovered $50,000 for loss of society and companionship. We prepared him thoroughly for his testimony — the way we prepare every client — so the jury could understand exactly what this injury had taken from their life together.
“The property owner says no one ever fell here before. Does that defeat my claim?”
No. The fact that no one happened to be hurt by a dangerous condition before you does not make the condition safe — and in the right case, the owner should not even be allowed to argue it. Lawyers call this “negative evidence”: the absence of prior accidents is not proof that the property was safe, only that you may have been the first to be hurt. A court can keep that argument away from the jury.
The restaurant prepared elaborate charts showing how many people visited each year without a fall down this stairway. On our motion, the court kept that evidence out as improper negative evidence — so the jury judged the actual condition of the stairway, not the restaurant’s luck up to that point.
“The insurance company made no offer and is blaming me. What happens if we go to trial and win?”
You may end up recovering more than the verdict. Wisconsin has an offer-of-settlement rule: if you make a formal settlement offer before trial, the other side rejects it, and the jury then returns a verdict equal to or greater than your offer, the defendant can be required to pay not only the full verdict but also interest from the date of that offer and double your taxable costs. In other words, an insurance company that refuses a fair pre-trial offer and gambles on trial can pay a real price for it.
The restaurant made no offer at all before trial — it blamed our client and relied on the “no prior falls” evidence that was never going to be admitted. We had served a formal offer of settlement before trial under Wisconsin’s offer-of-settlement rule. Because the verdict exceeded our offer, the defendant was required to pay the entire verdict plus interest and double costs. When the defense later tried to negotiate a reduced payoff by threatening further appeal, we declined — our client was entitled to interest on the full verdict — and the defendant paid it all.
“My case was lost once — is it over?”
Not necessarily. Trials can be lost because of legal errors that have nothing to do with the strength of your case — including a judge giving the jury the wrong instructions about the law. Those errors can be appealed, and a case can be retried. A loss is not always the end.
We lost the first trial — but not because the case was weak. The first judge instructed the jury that we had to prove the restaurant knew the open stairway was dangerous. That was wrong. In a Wisconsin safe-place case, the focus is on the condition of the property, not on what the owner knew or did not know. For a structural defect like an open stairway, no such notice is required — and in any event the owner plainly knew the stairway was there. We appealed, the instruction error was corrected, we retried the case, and this time the jury held the restaurant responsible.
One more thing the jury never got to see — but you should know
In most injury cases, the fact that a property owner fixed a hazard after someone was hurt cannot be used against them. But Wisconsin’s safe-place law contains a specific exception: evidence that a dangerous condition was later repaired is admissible to prove a safe-place violation. That rule can shape how — and when — a defendant chooses to fix the very hazard it claimed could not be fixed.
Through both trials, the restaurant argued it was not feasible to block off the open stairway because employees used it during business hours. Shortly after the second trial, the stairway was blocked off. Because this was a safe-place case — where later repairs can be admissible to prove a violation — the timing speaks for itself.
The result: A jury held the restaurant responsible, and our clients recovered the full verdict plus interest and double costs — after the defense offered nothing before trial, lost once, appealed, and lost again on retrial. A fractured wrist the insurer dismissed, a husband’s own real loss, a defense built on evidence that never came in, and a wrong jury instruction corrected on appeal: together, that is what it can take to make a property owner answer for an unsafe condition.
If you were seriously hurt in a fall and the property owner is blaming you
Mingo & Yankala has a strong history of representing people seriously injured on unsafe property across Wisconsin — including serious falls, back and spinal injuries, fractured bones, traumatic brain injury and post-concussion syndrome, and rotator cuff injuries. Attorney Mark Mingo is Board Certified in Civil Trial Law and has tried more than 100 cases to verdict.
We know how property owners and their insurers defend these cases — blaming the injured person, claiming “no one ever fell here before,” and offering little or nothing until they are made to answer to a jury. We take serious premises cases to trial, and we use every tool the law provides — including Wisconsin’s safe-place statute and its offer-of-settlement rule — to make that happen. If you or a loved one was seriously injured in a fall in Wisconsin, talk to us before you accept that your case is worth less than it is.