How We Turned a Serious Back Injury Into a $3,225,000 Truck Settlement

How We Turned a Serious Back Injury Into a $3,225,000 Truck Settlement

A real Wisconsin truck case—and what it shows about proving your injuries and the true cost of your future care when the trucking company’s insurer fights back.

A semi-truck slammed into our client’s car as it sat stopped in traffic on a Milwaukee interstate. The crash caused serious, permanent injuries and, as happens in almost every large truck case, the trucking company’s insurer fought hard to pay as little as possible. In the end, the case settled for $3,225,000. Here is how it was built, and what it shows about the questions injured people ask us most after a truck crash.

“The truck driver hit me — but can I hold the trucking company responsible?”

Often, yes—and it can matter a great deal. A trucking company is not just responsible for the crash itself; it can be independently responsible for putting an unsafe driver on the road in the first place. If a company hires a driver it should not have hired—a driver with a poor record, or one it never properly checked out—and fails to train that driver adequately, the company can be liable for negligent hiring, retention, and training. That matters to you because the company, and its much larger insurance coverage, is brought squarely into the case.

HOW THIS PLAYED OUT IN OUR $3,225,000 CASE: Even though the basic fault for the crash was not seriously in dispute, we developed proof that the driver should never have been hired: he had a prior record that made him a poor risk, and the trucking company either failed to perform a proper background check or did not care what it would have found. Our expert was prepared to testify that the driver was inadequately trained and should not have been behind the wheel. That evidence put the company’s own conduct—not just the driver’s—in front of the other side.

“The insurance company says my other injuries aren’t from the crash because they didn’t show up right away. Can I still recover for them?”

Yes—and this is one of the most common and unfair arguments insurers make. When someone suffers a severe injury in a crash, that injury can be so overwhelming, so painful and disabling—that it masks other, less dramatic injuries. The person (and sometimes even the doctors) are focused on the worst problem first. The other injuries are real and were caused by the same crash; they simply are not the loudest voice in the room until the main injury is being managed. Insurers exploit the gap by pointing to the medical records and saying, “if it isn’t written down on day one, it didn’t happen in the crash.” That is not how serious injuries actually work, and the right medical testimony can explain why.

HOW THIS PLAYED OUT IN OUR $3,225,000 CASE: Our client’s most serious injury was to the back—ultimately two failed back surgeries and permanent disability. There were also injuries to the right knee, both shoulders, and the neck. The defense argued those additional injuries were unrelated to the crash because they did not appear in the medical records until roughly four and a half months after it. Through our medical expert, we showed the jury the truth: the back injury was so severe that it masked the knee, shoulder, and neck injuries—which is precisely why they did not surface in the records until the back was being addressed. The “they’re unrelated” defense did not hold up.

“Who pays for the surgeries and care I will still need years from now?”

You are entitled to recover not only the medical care you have already received, but the reasonable cost of the care you will need in the future because of your injury—and in a serious case, that is often where most of the value is. The key is proving it with real numbers, not guesswork. That means identifying the specific future treatment a person will need, pricing it out, and accounting for the hard reality that for many permanent injuries, the cost of care increases over time, not decreases, as the body deteriorates and more intervention is required.

HOW THIS PLAYED OUT IN OUR $3,225,000 CASE: We did not ask the jury to guess. We obtained the medical diagnostic codes for the future treatment our client would require, and worked with the hospital’s own billing department to calculate what that future surgery and care would actually cost. We then showed that, far from tapering off, the cost of this lifelong treatment would increase with time as the condition worsened. Concrete, documented future damages—rather than a round-number estimate—are a major reason the recovery reached $3,225,000.

The result: The case settled for $3,225,000. A serious back injury, the trucking company’s own hiring failures, a defense that tried to write off most of the injuries as unrelated, and a rigorously documented lifetime of future care—together, that is what a properly built truck case looks like.

If you were seriously hurt in a truck crash and the insurance company is already pushing back…

Mingo & Yankala has a strong history of representing people seriously injured in Wisconsin truck and semi crashes—including back and spinal injuries, traumatic brain injury, and other catastrophic, permanent injuries. Attorney Mark Mingo is Board Certified in Civil Trial Law and has tried more than 100 cases to verdict.

We know how trucking companies and their insurers defend these cases—the “your injuries aren’t related” argument, the pressure to settle before the full picture is clear, the reluctance to pay for the future care you will actually need. We build serious truck cases to prove every piece of the harm, including the care you will need for the rest of your life. If you or a loved one was seriously injured by a truck in Wisconsin, talk to us before you accept that your case is worth less than it is.

Trucking insurer denied coverage? Read about the MCS-90 endorsement

Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. Every case is different, and the outcome of any case depends on its own particular facts and circumstances.